14 Best Insoles for Cowboy Boots

Best Insoles for Cowboy Boots

Historically, cowboy boots have been pretty famous, and not just because of how good they look, but also because they allowed horseback riders in the olden days to ride their horses without slipping.

You have to admit; cowboy boots look pretty chic with their leather exterior and slight heel. They look even better if you have a matching cowboy hat to complete the look. However, they’re not always the most comfortable shoes to wear, and they’re not the type which you can “break-in” by walking around in them for a long time. Wearing cowboy boots without insoles is generally painful and can adversely affect your back and legs.

Insoles provide extra padding inside your boots and may be designed differently for pointy-toed and square-toed boots. Apart from protecting your feet from getting grazed and blistered by the interior of your boots, they also provide a high level of comfort for people who wear cowboy boots as their regular footwear.

What You Need to Know Before Buying Insoles for Your Cowboy Boots

Before we get into which insoles are best for you, let’s take a look at cowboy boots, cowboy boot insoles and what you need to know before buying them for your boots:

How to Buy the Right Sized Cowboy Boots

Cowboy boots can be quite pricey, especially if you buy good quality ones, and getting the right fitting boots is no small feat. Here is everything you need to look at to get the right fit:

  • The Ball of the Foot – despite the heel of your cowboy boots, you need to be able to stand comfortably in them with the weight evenly distributed across your whole foot. Since the ball of your foot is the widest part, this is where you need to start measuring. A rule of thumb is that the widest part of your boot should be the widest part of your foot.
  • The Width –to keep you from getting a million blisters on your feet, your boots need to be the right width without being so big that your feet slide around inside. The best way to tell is to stand up in your boots and look down at your feet. The shoes should be a snug fit, but should still allow you to have a complete view of the stitching on the outsoles. If you can’t see the stitching on the outsoles, the boots aren’t wide enough.
  • Heel Slippage –since these boots have a slight heel, the heel of your foot might not be able to get a proper grip. This is alright since it will settle in once you’ve broken in the outsole of the boot. Separately putting in an insole will also greatly help with this.

How to Get the Right Size When Shopping Online

If you’re buying your boots online, take proper care to get the right size. Don’t just make an assumption based on your standard shoe size – the fit of a cowboy boot is significantly different than your everyday pair of sneakers.

The best way to get the right size is to measure the length and width of your foot. Start by tracing the outline of your foot on a sheet of paper. Measure it and subtract 0.02 units from each measurement for accuracy.

Some insoles may even ask you to specify certain information, such as how big your instep is, how arched your foot is, etc.

Wearing Cowboy Boots without Insoles Can Affect Your Posture

No matter how good cowboy boots look, especially if you’re going horse riding, they can negatively affect your posture because:

  • The heel of your cowboy boots will wear down after extensive use – if the heel is pressed down at an angle, it can change your posture, which may eventually lead to back and hip pain.
  • Cowboy boots come with generic insoles that may not suit the shape of your feet and can be painful to walk in.
  • Despite having a smooth base, the bottom of your cowboy boots do not provide enough traction and will wear out quickly, leading to the problems discussed in the previous two points.
  • Apart from the outside of the boots, the interior is also susceptible to wear-and-tear. This may result in you exerting extra pressure on your heels as you walk, which will quite obviously impact your posture and cause leg and back pain.

Getting the right insoles for your feet can help you avert all these problems. It also acts as a cushion between the base of the shoe and the floor and absorbs the shock of your body when your foot hits the ground.

What Exactly Are Insoles?

Insoles are essentially pieces of material that are inserted on the inner base of your shoes to either make them more comfortable, provide warmth, or to give the boots a more snug fit if you’ve got the wrong-sized shoes. They may also be known as footbeds or inner soles and serve the main purpose of making your shoes (or boots) more comfortable to wear.

They’re also a great way to keep your shoes fresh and can always be taken out and cleaned if they get dirty. If your shoes are too big, they can even be paired with toe inserts for maximum support.

What Are the Main Features of a Good Insole for Cowboy Boots?

The best insoles will ensure that your posture doesn’t get affected as you walk and that you are comfortable, even if you wear the boots all day long. The core features of good cowboy boots include:

  • A Stable Base– this will ensure that your feet stay in place and don’t move around. A rigid base will provide the best level of support and stability. Some insoles have padding that may be made of a gel layer for extra cushioning.
  • Arch Support – a good insole will always provide solid arch support. This will keep your feet properly aligned, maintain the right posture, and keep you away from any kind of leg or back pain. This will also ensure that your boots wear down evenly. Some insoles have adaptable arch support that molds according to the shape of your feet for additional stability.
  • A Deep Heel Cup – this will keep you from exerting too much pressure on your foot as you move. It will help distribute pressure evenly across your foot, which will allow you to walk without getting tired too quickly.
  • Moisture Wicking Material – this material doesn’t absorb sweat and causes it to dry at the surface, keeping the inside of your boots clean and dry all day long.

Additional Benefits of Insoles for Cowboy Boots

Apart from helping you maintain the right posture and providing support, insoles have other benefits, such as:

  • Increasing the longevity of your boots
  • Preventing sweat from building up inside your boots and keeping your feet clean all day long. Apart from making you feel good, this also keeps bacteria buildup at bay.

What Material is Your Insole Made of?

Materials that are commonly used in the making of cowboy boot insoles include:

  • Foam – foam is probably the most common material used to make insoles. This is because it is inexpensive, shock absorbent, rigid, and still provides a little bit of flexibility to allow the insole to bend somewhat according to the movement of your feet. It might not, however, be the most durable material.
  • Memory Foam –memory foam is soft and significantly more flexible than regular foam, making it really comfortable to walk on. This also means that memory foam is more durable.
  • Gel –this is a particularly good material for shoes with a heel, such as, well, cowboy boots. They increase your grip, reduce slippage, and provide pain relief, especially for the balls of your feet.
  • Air-Cushioned Insoles – as the name suggests, air-cushioned insoles contain pressurized air bubbles inside the foam insole to provide a very high level of cushioning. Subsequently, these air-cushioned insoles also make your shoes last longer.
  • Leather –this is generally good for providing arch support, though it is quite tough and doesn’t provide a lot of cushioning. Many people may also avoid it since they may prefer a vegan option.

Depending on the brand and product you choose, many of these materials will be treated with a solution to make them antimicrobial to keep fungi and harmful bacteria (that are likely to be caused by sweat) away.

How to Maintain Your Insoles

If you’ve finally managed to get your hands on insoles for your boots, it’s your job to ensure that they actually last for some time and stay in good shape. The best way to do this is to clean and deodorize them, which will also prevent a nasty smell from accumulating in your boots. You can use a number of products, such as baking soda, a rag with some vinegar, or talcum powder to air them out.

If they are really dirty and stinky, you can hand wash them in lukewarm water and soap them gently with a soft-bristled brush. Don’t put them in the washing machine since this is likely to wear them out really fast.

If your feet sweat more than average, choose insoles that are made of a material that won’t deteriorate too quickly due to the extra moisture.

We’ve put together a list of the best insoles for cowboy boots so that you can walk around in them all day without any discomfort:

Our Top Picks

Out of all of the cowboy boot insoles that we’re going to discuss in this article, our top 3 choices for the best insoles for cowboy boots are:

  1. The Best Overall Product: Timberland PRO Anti-Fatigue Footbed Powered by Fcx Technology Insole
  2. Best Premium Option: Samurai Instant Relief Orthotics for Flat Feet
  3. Best Value Buy: Sof Soles Insoles AIRR for Men & Women

Best Insoles for Cowboy Boots

1. Timberland PRO Anti-Fatigue Footbed Powered by Fcx Technology Insole

Timberland PRO Anti-Fatigue Footbed Powered by Fcx Technology Insole

Timberland has been catering to the desires of boot lovers for a long time. This orange and black insole is designed to help you feel comfortable, even if you’re constantly on-the-go (which is the case with most cowboys). Fcx technology is meant to provide support and strength and keep you from getting tired too quickly. This is all possible due to the way the insole is shaped.

The insoles are designed to be shock-absorbent and go one step ahead by converting this shock into energy to help you stay on your feet 24/7. They have a top layer made of OrthoLite, which provides cushioning and prevents moisture from penetrating below the surface, keeping the inside of your shoes dry and clean. This function is aided by the mesh lining and Agion treating of the insoles, which keeps bacteria at bay. The rest of the insole below the OrthoLite is synthetic, adding some flexibility and slowing down its wear and tear.

The forefoot of the insole has small holes that provide ventilation and allow air to pass freely through your boots.

The arch design is somewhat generic and suitable for most foot types. The footbed has a contoured design to provide cushioning, stability, and comfort.

It is one of the more well-cushioned and slightly thicker insoles, making it ideal for women’s cowboy boots and boots with a slightly taller heel. It is available for both men and women across a range of sizes from Small to Extra Extra Large.

With a solid design, these insoles are suitable for any kind of heavy-duty shoe, not just cowboy boots. 

Pros of the Timberland Insoles

  • Thick cushioning
  • Universal fit
  • Moisture repellant design making it durable
  • The insoles are available at a reasonable price.

Cons of the Timberland Insoles

  • The insoles may not be as durable as they’re advertised to be
  • In some cases, the insoles may need to be cut down to size.

Buy on Amazon


2. Sof Sole Insoles Women’s AIRR Orthotic Support for Western Boots

Sof Sole Airr Orthotic Full Length Performance Shoe Insoles, Black, Women's 8-11

These green and black insoles are composed of a number of layers designed for additional stability and comfort. These insoles have gel padding throughout for cushioning and to act as a shock-absorber. The arch has a nylon plate for added grip.

Sof Sole manufactures insoles for both men and women and uses the latest technology to design and produce durable and comfortable insoles. A major plus point for these insoles is that they eliminate one of the main problems associated with long term wear of cowboy boots – unevenness in the base of the boot due to wear-and-tear.

Apart from its gel padding, the insole incorporates Skydex technology in both the arch and the heel. Skydex technology involves the use of air bubbles, which reduce the impact on your body when your feet strike the ground. It also adds some height to the heel, making it taller than the forefoot of the insole and evening out the interior of the boot.

The nylon plate in the arch of the insole is especially useful for people with low-arched feet – it keeps your feet properly aligned and helps you control the movement of your feet better.

The insoles also feature Coolmax technology, which is designed to maintain your body temperature. It includes a fabric cover that wicks moisture away from your feet and ensures that they remain dry and clean. It also keeps sweat and bad smell away. This fabric cover is also treated with antimicrobial spray to keep germs away.

While these are great insoles for women’s boots, perhaps the only real issue with them is that they are best for people with low-arched feet.

Pros of the Sof Soles for Women

  • Skydex air bubble technology for shock absorbency
  • Coolmax technology for temperature control
  • Gel padding for cushioning

Cons of the Sof Soles for Women

  • Suitable only for women with low-arched feet.

Buy on Amazon


3. Sof Sole Insoles Men’s AIRR Performance Walking Boots Insert

Sof Sole Men's Airr Insole, Black, Men's 13-14

Sof Sole has some great inserts, not just for women’s boots, but also for men’s boots. The two are actually quite similar, with some obvious differences, such as the fact that the women’s insoles have contours to fit their feet.

These insoles have gel padding for extra cushioning and make use of Skydex technology, which includes air bubbles for shock absorbency. In addition, they convert the impact on your body into kinetic energy to help you move faster and feel less tired.

The antimicrobial properties of the insoles keep your feet from sweating too much and kill off germs that can cause a stink in your boots. This works in combination with the Coolmax feature to keep your feet and shoes dry and moisture-free.

The footbed along the entire length of the insole is made of a foamy, flexible layer of polyurethane for proper cushioning and comfort, no matter what angle your foot moves at. This flexibility is actually quite important since your feet curve as you move, and the insole needs to adapt to your movement pattern.

The AIRR insoles work best for people with medium-arched feet and are a solid option, not just for cowboy boots, but for any other shoes that may be used for high-intensity activities. They add a level of traction and don’t allow your feet to slide around inside your boots.

The insoles are suitable for most men with a range of sizes from 7-14.

Pros of Sof Soles AIRR Performance Walking Boots Insert

  • Suitable for pretty much any type of foot
  • Skydex technology for extra padding
  • Coolmax technology to keep your boots dry
  • Flexible foam fits the curves of your feet.

Cons of Sof Soles AIRR Performance Walking Boots Insert

  • Works best for men with medium-arched feet
  • The insole may turn out to be smaller than the displayed size.

Buy on Amazon


4. Samurai Instant Relief Orthotics for Flat Feet

Samurai Insoles Instant Relief Orthotics for Flat Feet - Plantar Fasciitis Pain Relief Guaranteed, Arch Support Shoe Insert Insoles for Foot and Heel Pain M10-10.5/W12-12.5

These aren’t just insoles – they’re an insole and orthotic combined into one. The entire length of the shoe insert acts as an insole with the orthotics section offering additional comfort from your arch to your heels. This is particularly because your arch and heel are more susceptible to shock than other parts of your feet, and additional cushioning can drastically lessen the impact.

The insoles provide comfort and are quite helpful in correcting foot problems and disorders such as plantar fasciitis, flat foot, and pain in the arch, the ball of your foot, and your heel. They also lessen knee and hip pain and hammertoe. Most of these problems are a frequent complaint by cowboy boot wearers because of the way the boot is constructed and the leather hide used to make the boots.

It can seem a little unrealistic that an insole can help deal with so many foot and joint problems, but this orthotic has been designed by podiatrists who understand these problems better than anyone else.

These insoles, despite providing a decent amount of cushioning, are quite lightweight and can easily fit inside your cowboy boots. They will ensure that when you take your boots off after a long day of work, your feet won’t be too sore. Apart from fitting into your cowboy boots, they can also work for other types of shoes, such as office shoes, running shoes, etc. 

Pros of the Samurai Orthotics

  • Helpful for people with flat feet and those with other foot disorders
  • Are a less expensive option to custom-designed insoles for flat-footed people

Cons of the Samurai Orthotics

  • Not very durable
  • The padding is a little thin
  • The red color of the insoles may rub off on the inside of your boots and your socks.

Buy on Amazon


5. Bickmore Cowgirl Boot Insole

Bickmore Work Insoles for Women | Gel Lightweight Support Insole | Great for Work Shoes, Riding & Cowboy Boots | Once Size Fits All | Cut to Size

Bickmore has been around for quite a while now and has picked up enough expertise to put out some high-quality products. Unlike other insoles where you can’t always be sure about the quality or the benefits they offer, these ones are likely to tick all the boxes discussed in the previous section.

These Bickmore insoles are specifically designed to act as shock absorbers, particularly in the heel, instep, and toe areas.

Since cowboy boots are quite pointy in the front, these insoles are designed to keep those areas of your feet more comfortable. It provides a sufficient level of padding to keep pain and stress away from your feet and to lighten the pressure.

These insoles have in-built antiseptic properties to eliminate any germs that might leave an unpleasant smell behind in your shoes. Unlike many other insoles, this design comes in a single, universal size, and this same insole can work for cowboy boots and work shoes. If the insoles don’t fit into your boots, you can quite easily trim them down to size by either tracing out the bottom of the boot or using your old insoles as a guide.

Although these insoles may not cater to people with special conditions such as a flat foot or foot disorders like plantar fasciitis, they are an inexpensive foot insert for people who occasionally wear their cowboy boots and don’t really have any heavy-duty work involved. 

Pros of the Bickmore Insole

  • Quite inexpensive
  • Decent quality, especially based on their price point

Cons of the Bickmore Insole

  • Not very durable
  • Padding is a little too thin
  • They are only suitable for cowboy boots.

Buy on Amazon


6. Danner Men’s DXT Comfort Footbed for Boots

Danner Men's DXT Comfort Footbed

As the name itself suggests, these insoles are designed specifically for boots and have been crafted to provide a comfortable footbed and a dual-layered shock-absorbent system with tri-density heel protection.

In layman’s terms, these insoles provide enough grip and cushioning to provide relief to three key areas of your body that are most likely to be impacted by your movement and poor posture – the heels, the arches, and the knees. Apart from providing pain relief, the multiple layers of the insoles will make you feel like you are walking on a smooth, soft, cloud-like surface.

It has X-Static lining designed to keep your feet cool and dry and free of fungi, which are most likely to be the result of sweat accumulation. The insoles also have a TPU X feature, which includes a heel stabilizing cup to provide extra support and shock absorbency.

Furthermore, they offer the flexibility of moving with the changing shape of your feet as you move, which is probably one of the most important factors to look at when getting insoles for your boots. The flexibility comes from the memory foam used in the layers of the insoles.

These are one of the more durable insoles since they are made of long-lasting, synthetic material. This is a double bonus since the longer your insole lasts and protects your foot and boot, the longer your cowboy boots are likely to last. 

Pros of the Danner Men’s Insoles

  • Provides triple-layered cushioning
  • Available in a range of sizes – from 6-14 and the fit is always as expected
  • Have orthotic properties at a lower price point than custom-made ones.

Cons of the Danner Men’s Insoles

  • Some of the layers may show signs of peeling after extensive use
  • Sizing isn’t based on a universal fit.

Buy on Amazon


7. Enerfoot Arch Support Boot Insoles

High Arch Support Insoles for Men Women Orthotic Shoe Inserts Plantar Fasciitis Inserts Super Support Shoe Inserts

Enerfoot makes itself stand out with a unique insole design. What makes these insoles different from the rest is the u-shaped heel cup designed to provide a solid grip for your heels, provide support for your ankle joint, and make moving around all day in your cowboy boots comfortable.

The ergonomic design evenly distributes the weight on your feet so that your posture remains correct, and so that you don’t experience fatigue or discomfort after a little while.

The heel includes gel padding to relieve stress and reduce the impact on your feet. The gel padding is also further encased in a solid coating of Thermoplastic Polyurethane (TPU) for solid arch support. The design was made to ensure that your metatarsal (the central bone structure of the foot) has sufficient cushioning and support.

The entire insole is designed to ensure 100% breathability to prevent sweat and smell accumulation and to keep your feet and boots dry and clean.

These unisex insoles are available in a range of sizes and come with a sizing guide in case you need to trim them to fit your boots. They are especially comfortable for people with high-arched feet. They have orthotic properties and are suitable for rough use, especially for people who are prone to experiencing discomfort and fatigue.

These insoles cater to any type of feet and are ideal for any type of use, from casual to hardcore usage.

Pros of the Enerfoot Arch Support Insoles

  • Useful for people with foot diseases such as plantar fasciitis
  • Suitable for pretty much any type of foot
  • Help in improving posture
  • Have orthotic properties at a low price point, unlike custom-made designs.

Cons of the Enerfoot Arch Support Insoles

  • All the comfort-maximizing features are focused on the arch of your foot.

Buy on Amazon


8. Bringsine Cowboy Boot Insole

Bringsine Shoe Insoles, Orthotic Insoles, Orthopedic Insoles, Foam Insoles - Excellent Shock Absorption & Cushioning, Shoe Inserts for Running, Hiking and More - Men & Women Everyday Use 1 Pair M

Some of the other insoles we’ve discussed that had one main standout quality; the Bringsine insoles have two main, distinguishable features – they are ultra-lightweight and are made of a soft, memory foam to provide cushioning and comfort as you walk.

As you know, cowboy boots aren’t necessarily the most comfortable to wear – these insoles reduce the friction between your feet and the inside of your boots and keep you safe from blisters, bruises, and that feeling of suffocation when you’ve been walking for too long.

These insoles have tiny holes that serve the purpose of keeping your shoes ventilated. The design features ridges that provide a solid grip.

The built-in carbon fiber keeps your feet and boots dry and clean and eliminates the smell of sweat. The insoles are breathable and allow fresh air to circulate through the inside of the boots. They also have a full arch shell for additional support and stability, ensuring that your feet stay properly aligned and your posture is correct.

The insoles are quite easy to trim if they don’t fit inside your boots. These unisex insoles are great for anything, from running to hiking to just going out for a casual stroll. They are latex-free and, therefore, an excellent option for anyone who has any latex allergies. 

Pros of the Bringsine Insoles

  • Breathable design
  • Excellent arch support
  • Help correct posture.

Cons of the Bringsine Insoles

  • Not the most durable insoles on the market
  • The heel may start deteriorating before the rest of the insoles.

Buy on Amazon


9. JobSite Dura Gel Comfort Insoles

JobSite Dura Gel Comfort Insoles - US Women 6-11 (Trim to Fit)

The JobSite insoles have a number of useful features – they are shock-absorbent, provide additional support, and have a gel layer below the arch, heels, and forefoot. To add to all these amazing features, these insoles are also quite mesmerizing to look at.

The top layer of the insoles is breathable and disperses any heat that may accumulate if you move around too much. The material is designed to wick moisture away and is soft enough to reduce the friction between your foot and the inside of your shoe.

The insoles have an Aegis microbe shield to keep smell-causing bacteria and fungi at bay. Like some other different types of insoles, these ones also come with a trim guide in case you need to trim them to fit inside your boots.

As you walk, these shoes have a massaging effect to keep your feet comfortable and free from fatigue.

Pros of the JobSite Insoles

  • Provides a high level of cushioning
  • Designed to ensure stress relief
  • Gel padding for extra support
  • Breathable build
  • Quite inexpensive
  • These insoles have antimicrobial properties.

Cons of the JobSite Insoles

  • A little tricky to trim.

Buy on Amazon


10. StepComfy Unisex Moldable Adaptive Support Insoles for Cowboy Boots

Moderate Flat Feet/Fallen Arches Metatarsal Support Orthotics Insoles/Inserts/Pads for,Feet Pain,Over-Pronation,Ball of Foot Pain (US Men(9.5-10)-Women(11.5-12)-11.22"-285MM)

As the brand name indicates, these insoles are designed to make every step you take extremely comfortable, even if you’re wearing something as uncomfortable as cowboy boots.

The insoles are made up of 5 different layers that work together to provide cushioning, arch support, and remove the pressure on your feet that is the result of constant impacts with the ground. Two of these layers are made of cork material, which essentially serves the same purpose as a memory foam insole – to provide flexibility and breathability for maximum comfort.

This cork is also paired with foam that provides a moisture-wicking effect to keep your boots and feet dry and clean. These insoles also have a U-shaped heel cup to provide stability to your heels. The anti-slip design helps you maintain a solid grip on the ground.

The StepComfy insoles have orthotic properties and are ideal for anyone who experiences foot discomfort or ailments such as plantar fasciitis, pronation, and heel pain or are simply flat-footed.

Pros of the StepComfy Insoles

  • Ideal for flat-footed people and those with minimal arching
  • Comes with a warranty
  • Includes an EVA foam layer
  • Multi-layered cushioning
  • Available in a range of sizes for both men and women.

Cons of the StepComfy Insoles

  • The thick arch support might feel a little hard at times.

Buy on Amazon


11. Thorogood Unisex Commando Insoles Dual Density Insoles for Cowboy Boots

Thorogood Men's 889-8000 The Deuce Shock Zone Footbed, Red - L (10-11.5)

The Thorogood insoles provide a level of comfort not generally associated with cowboy boots. Made of a solid layer of polyurethane, these insoles are contoured to provide a natural grip to your feet and provide support and traction.

They include gel padding, which is shock absorbent and provides stress and pain relief after walking around in your boots all day. The breathable top layer of the insoles keeps sweat from accumulating and allows air circulation, keeping the inside of your boots clean and dry.

They are especially useful for people with foot conditions such as flat-footedness or problems like plantar fasciitis. These men’s inserts cater to a wide range of sizes, including some large ones for people with long feet – available in sizes 6-15.

 Pros of the Thorogood Insoles

  • Durable, even if used for high-intensity tasks daily
  • Perfect fit (with maybe a very slight trim required)
  • Good quality.

 Cons of the Thorogood Insoles

  • It might not provide the cushioning and comfort required by people who suffer from foot pain and other ailments.

Buy on Amazon


12. Ariat Men’s Ats Round Toe Footbeds

Ariat Men's ATS Round Toe Footbeds, Multi, 12

Ariat has been around for quite a while, producing quality products for people who work outdoors, horseback riders, and those who just love to stay out and about.

These round-toed insoles are designed for men’s boots and come in a range of sizes, from 7-14. They incorporate Advanced Torque Stability (ATS) technology to provide solid support, pain relief, and reduce fatigue.

The heel and the ball of the insoles have gel padding, again providing pain relief, comfort, and solid support.

The top layer of the insoles is made of moisture-wicking material to keep the inside of your boots clean and dry. The insoles are made of polyurethane.

Pros of the Ariat Round Toe Footbeds

  • Good range of sizes – possible to get a perfect fit
  • Gel padding for cushioning and pain relief
  • Moisture-wicking to prevent your boots from getting stuffy
  • Are quite reasonably priced.

Cons of the Ariat Round Toe Footbeds

  • Might not provide enough arch support
  • Not very durable.

Buy on Amazon


13. Ariat Men’s Ats Footbed Wide Square Toe Insoles

Ariat Men's ATS Footbed Wide Square Toe-10008009, Multi, 13

Ariat has been putting out some pretty decent products, so it’s no wonder we have two of these on our list. The brand understands the comfort sought by people who wear cowboy boots. What really makes these insoles stand out is that they are square-toed and come in a pretty wide range of sizes, from 7-15, meaning that it’s always possible for you to find the perfect fit. This sizing corresponds with the actual size of your boots, so you know which one you need to get.

The best part is that since they’re already square-toed, you won’t need to trim them to size for square-front boots. Like the previous ones, these insoles also incorporate ATS (Advanced Torque Stability) technology to provide extra support for your feet.

They provide a solid amount of cushioning and reduce fatigue, making you feel comfortable all the time. They are great for people with wide feet with the widest part of the insole measuring 14 inches.

The insoles contain gel padding at the ball of the foot and the heel for stability and pain relief. This also helps you maintain good posture and makes walking on a hard surface easier.

The top layer of the insoles is made of moisture-wicking material to keep the inside of your boots nice and clean. If you notice the buildup of moisture or dirt, just hand wash and air dry them before placing them back inside your boots. 

Pros of the Ariat Square Toe Insoles

  • Accurate sizing
  • Gel padding for comfort and pain relief
  • A square design ideal for square-toe boots
  • Quite reasonably priced.

Cons of the Ariat Square Toe Insoles

  • No microbial properties
  • The upper fabric may start balling up under your feet over time.

Buy on Amazon


14. RockRooster Unisex Work Boot Insoles

ROCKROOSTER Insoles for Work Boots, Mens/Women Shoes Insole, Arch Support, Memory Foam, Anti-Fatigue(Red, M9 W10.5)

Unlike some of the previous ones on this list, these insoles are for both men and women. They are designed specifically for people who experience frequent foot pain and fatigue.

They incorporate Coolmax technology to maintain the temperature of your boots and to keep moisture away. They’re also really soft and lightweight and protect your feet from getting blistered and bruised inside your cowboy boots.

The top layer has antimicrobial properties, getting rid of harmful bacteria and fungi as well as the smell of sweat. They also help you avoid infections that are likely to cause foot pains.

Their design caters to people who are flat-footed or have low arches and has an ergonomic fit for constant comfort.

The insoles have a raised heel cup, which is a major plus point, and with that, they also combine gel padding for shock absorbency ensuring that your body doesn’t have to deal with the shock of the impact on the ground and that your weight is distributed evenly across your feet, not just focused on one area such as your heel or your arches. 

Pros of the RockRooster Insoles

  • Reasonably priced
  • Available in a range of sizes for men and women – from 6-15
  • Available in different colors
  • The soles have antimicrobial properties
  • Gel padding for shock absorbency
  • Work well, not only for cowboy boots but for sneakers as well.

Cons of the RockRooster Insoles

  • Very slightly slippery
  • Don’t provide enough heel support – no orthotic properties.

Buy on Amazon


And the Winners Are

Now that we’ve covered the basics of cowboy boots and what to expect from your insoles, it’s time to pick our winners that tick all the right boxes:

The Best Overall Product

 Timberland PRO Anti-Fatigue Footbed Powered by Fcx Technology Insole

Combining a solid price with a solid design, the Timberland insoles have everything you could possibly need in a shoe insert. It is a high quality, durable insole which is slightly on the thicker side and provides a pretty solid level of cushioning. Combine this with its antibacterial technology and moisture-wicking properties, and this insole will make your otherwise uncomfortable cowboy boots a treat to walk in. Another major bonus is that this unisex sole comes in a very wide range of sizes and caters to all types of feet.

The Best Premium Option

Samurai Instant Relief Orthotics for Flat Feet

The Samurai Orthotics may be the most expensive option we have for you, but their price doesn’t come anywhere near custom-designed orthotic inserts. Their shock-absorbency is excellent as is the cushioning they provide, which is why they’re a solid option for anyone with foot problems like flat-footedness, plantar fasciitis, and so on.

They provide solid heel and arch support and are still quite lightweight, making your overall walking experience comfortable. Unlike custom-made orthotics that can be drastically outside your budget, you can go for these Samurai orthotics that will help you look and feel good in your snazzy new cowboy boots (and yes, they’re suitable for both men and women).

The Best Value Buy

Sof Soles Insoles AIRR for Men & Women

Even though the Sof Sole insoles aren’t the least expensive ones on this list, they certainly offer the most value for money with a standout feature being that they take into account that men and women have different feet shapes and have tailored their insoles accordingly. They provide excellent arch support and have a Coolmax system to keep your feet from getting too stuffy. Perhaps their best feature is that they ensure that your boots wear down evenly – unevenness in your boots due to wear-and-tear is a leading cause of discomfort in cowboy boots and the reason why it ruins people’s posture.

The contours of the insoles align well with your feet and the foam body curves as you move to allow for changes in shape.

So Which Insoles Are the Best For Your Cowboy Boots?

The final call is yours – just remember to choose insoles that make wearing cowboy boots a comfortable experience, even if you never take them off. Look for factors that are essential for you; for instance, if your feet tend to sweat a lot, insoles with antimicrobial properties may be more important for you. If you experience foot pain or are flat-footed, you may need insoles with thicker cushioning and orthotic properties. Factors such as needing to trim your insoles down to size should not be deal-breakers, especially since most insoles come with a size guide to make this step quick and easy for you. And look at this as a plus point, since the insoles will end up being a 100% perfect fit.

Another important thing to remember is that no matter how dirty your insoles are, don’t be tempted to toss them in the washing machine. Rinse them by hand, and air dry them before inserting them back into your boots.

Leave a Comment